Starting your compost pile can be an overwhelming experience. What you may not realize is that there are different methods involved in the madness. Hot and cold composting are two of the most popular choices, not to mention worm or bokashi composting. You may be wondering — what’s the difference and which method is best? That being said, it’s all about personal preference (and a couple other factors.)

What is hot composting? 

Hot, also known as fast or active, composting is what may initially come to mind. By combining brown and green material, oxygen heats the compost to a temperature range between 100 and 160 degrees Fahrenheit. The easiest way to heat it up is rotating the compost or stirring it every 4 days. Another key factor with hot composting is moisture — it has a tendency to dry out, so always water when needed (via Fine Gardening).

Pros and cons of hot composting 

There are many pros and cons when it comes to hot composting. Typically, this method produces more compost, and has more nutrients and minerals (via GrowVeg).  The heat generated kills weeds seeds as well, and it also reduces unwanted smells. It takes less time for hot compost to break down — about 4 to 6 months typically (via Kansas Healthy Yards). On the flip side, this method takes more effort because you have to monitor the moisture and turn it weekly. It also requires more tools, such as a pitch fork, compost tumbler, or thermometer, making it less beginner-friendly. 

What is cold composting? 

Cold, also considered slow or passive, composting is not-so-surprisingly the opposite. It’s essentially putting all your organic materials into a pile and letting it slowly decompose over time — that’s it. Since there’s no stirring involved, it never gets hot, therefore taking longer to decompose. It’s more forgiving than hot composting in terms of the brown vs green balance, making it an easy method for beginners (via Compost Magazine). 

Pros and cons of cold composting 

On the other hand, cold composting has its fair share of pros and cons. The biggest downfall is that it takes about 6 to 12 months to fully decompose (via Kansas Healthy Yards). It’s also prone to mold, tends to smell more, and isn’t a compatible method for composting weeds (via Compost Magazine). That being said, it’s a cheaper, hands-off approach to composting, especially if you have a smaller-sized yard. 

Which option should you choose? 

This is a seemingly loaded question — it’s all about convenience and personal preference, since no choice is worse than the other. If you have the additional resources and a good-sized yard or garden, hot composting is the way to go. It may be more labor-intensive, but it’s worth it. If you need a lot of compost but don’t want to wait, the hot method is the go-to choice. On the other hand, if you are new to composting, the low-maintenance cold method may be the best option, especially if you’re in no rush. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *